Heads up! I take a pretty good look at storytelling and then I dive into how it can be applied to elearning. This is a geek-heavy episode, so be warned.
My stance is that we, as a species, have been telling stories for 40,000 plus years, and we're still telling stories so why are we using them improve our elearning. So where am I getting 40, 000 years from? Cave art. It's the first documented pictures ever created by man kind, and pictures tell stories. I suppose it's up for debate, but I won't listen to you. The nature of stories evolved along with us into a fairly complex set of events. Joseph Campbell was a mythologist who pointed out this series of events in The Hero's Journey. He created the Monomyth that breaks down all of the different steps that a hero or heroine goes through upon completing a story. Google your favorite movie and "hero's journey" and you'll be pleasantly surprised. I pulled a lot of the comic hero creation stories from Supergods by Grant Morrison.